Elections ’06: The Arizona 8th

mexico-arizona border

Arizona’s 8th Congressional District stretches north from the border to a bit of the southern Tucson suburbs, but a Democrat up in Tucson doesn’t necessarily want the same things as a Democrat down south. Tucson Democrats, explained Michael Marizco, author of Border Reporter, are more likely to volunteer to come south to supply water stations for border crossers; along the border, Democrats and Republicans both are more likely to have had their houses broken into as the same crossers emerge from the desert, desperate for food. In any case, Marizco believes, the closer you live to the border, the more likely you are to believe that the current policy of law enforcement isn’t working.

According to The Arizona Daily Star, Republican Randy Graf has made border security the centerpiece of his campaign, but trails Democrat Gabrielle Giffords, even among voters who say immigration is an important issue. The GOP has pulled advertising support from Graf’s campaign but can’t have given up completely; Graf has a local fundraiser scheduled with Karl Rove.

Marizco, no softy on border issues, believes the only solution is a guest worker program. How does the immigration debate change as you move toward the border, from up here in Boston down to Arizona, and from Tucson down to Douglas? What does a district that lives the border issue every day think about the national border postures of both parties?

Blake Morlock

Columnist, Tucson Citizen

Steve Lynn

Chairman, Arizona Indepdendent Redistricting Commission

David Stoddard

Twenty-Seven-Year Veteran, U.S. Customs and Border ProtectionResident, Santa Cruz County, Arizona

John Ellinwood

Blogger, Sonoran Alliance

Daniel Patterson

Blogger, Daniel’s News and Views

Ted Prezelski

Blogger, Rum, Romanism, and Rebellion
Extra Credit Reading
Blake Morlock, GOP committee’s foray into CD8 like a bad hangover, Tucson Citizen, September 25, 2006: “Maybe you know this guy. He’s drunk, walks into your house late at night, breaks something, tries to put it back together but makes a bigger mess. Then he leaves loudly and knocks over a trash can, waking neighbors as he disappears into the night.That’s how the National Republican Congressional Committee entered and then left the race to replace retiring Republican congressman Jim Kolbe.”

David Espo, GOP Drops Ariz. TV Ad Campaign, Washington Post, September 21, 2006

GOP Coming; Giffords Playing Huffman Dodgeball, Arizona 8th, September 26, 2006: “A recent GOP fundraiser where Click announced his “150%” support for Graf is another indicator that the party is coming together and making an effort to repair the damage inflicted during the primary.”

Jim Nintzel, High noon for immigration, Salon, October 2, 2006: “Democrats are poised to pick up a U.S. House seat in Arizona. Can Republican Randy Graf stop them by exploiting voters’ fears of illegal immigrants?”

AZ-8: GOP Wounds Healed?, Real Clear Politics, September 8, 2006: “Giffords, the Democrat, focused on Iraq and healthcare during the primary, but is now going to be in a contest where immigration dominates the political landscape.”

Marie Horrigan, Conservative Graf Scores Win Over Moderate in Arizona’s 8th, CQPolitics.com, September 13, 2006: “The race turned decidedly negative in recent weeks, with the National Republican Campaign Committee taking the unusual step of choosing sides in a primary race by launching ads supporting Huffman.”

Daniel Scarpinato, Demos find border a top issue in rural areas, Arizona Daily Star, June 18, 2006: “Elsewhere, [Democrats] use words like compromise and comprehensive. In this neck of the woods, Democrats talk enforcement.”

Mickey Kaus, Frist Fence Fakeout?, Slate, September 25, 2006: “Has Sen. Frist given up on the border fence? It sure sounded that way on George Stephanopoulos’ This Week.”

Related Content


  • I don’t know much about this race specifically, but it is interesting that Southwest Dems take a different stand on boarder secrurity. While not badmouthing immigrants in general, they do take bold steps to try to ensure safety along the boarder. Last summer New Mexico and Arizona Govs Bill Richardson and Janet Napolitano declared emergencies in several boarder counties, pointing out at the time that the federal government was doing little to ensure safety there.

  • jall

    Gabrielle Gifford, when asked in August what two politicians she looked up to and most admired,

    replied without any hesitation, “Hillary Clinton and Robert Reich.’ She is really not a moderate at all and when the voters find out how liberal she is they won’t be happy. Most of her TV commercials

    are fluff or out and out lies about her opponent.

  • Pingback: Publius » Flere interessante distrikter: Arizona 8()

  • Roger W. Capone

    We, as practicing Catholics, have no vehicle to air our grievences. The bishops are acting contrary to the wishes and mandates of our founder, Jesus Christ when He said of the lality “You are the servants of God, and you priest are the SERVENTS OF THE SERVENTS OF GOD. The duties of all priest, meaning all of the heirarchy of the Church, are to teach and bring the Good News of Christ to all Humanity.. When the bishop and the priest fail and commit grieveious sins, pedophilia, embezzelment etc.the laity has no recourse to seek redress. The bishop of Fall Rliver arrogantly refuses to talk, answer phone calls or letters , when approached by a lay person or organiztion VOTF with a grievence. He condems, out of hand, any group of concerned Catholics who form together to reform the Church.