Paul Harding’s Magical ‘Tinkers’

Paul HardingWhat is the rock drummer thinking? Well, if he’s the dazzling first-novelist Paul Harding of Tinkers, the guy at the drums in the band known as “Cold Water Flat” was channeling Elvin Jones, reinventing time with his own hands and feet on drumsticks and pedals. He was listening to hear how sound works, how the world works, how he works. He may have been composing a contrapuntal bit of narrative that turns up on paper in this exchange between an itinerant mule-and-cart peddlar named Howard Aaron Crosby and his customers in the backwoods of Maine, circa 1900.

Where’s the soap?

This is the soap.

The box is different.

Yes, they changed it.

What was wrong with the old box?


Why’d they change it?

Because the soap is better.

The soap is different?


Nothing wrong with the old soap.

Of course not, but this is better.

Nothing wrong with the old soap. How can it be better?

Well, it cleans better.

Cleaned fine before.

This cleans better — and faster.

Well, I’ll just take a box of the normal soap.

This is the normal soap now.

I can’t get my normal soap?

This is the normal soap; I guarantee it.

Well I don’t like to try a new soap.

It’s not new.

Just as you say, Mr. Crosby. Just as you say.

Well, ma’am, I need another penny.

Another penny? For what?

The soap is a penny more, now that it’s better.

I have to pay a penny more for different soap in a blue box? I’ll just take a box of my normal soap.

From Tinkers by Paul Harding, pages 13 – 14. Bellevue Literary Press, New York, 2009.

Paul Harding’s prose in that moment can remind you of Marshall Dodge’s old “Bert and I” Maine stories. It can also sound like music: “Tinker, tinker. Tin, tin, tin. Tintinnabulation. There was the ring of pots and buckets…” We hear light percussive sounds of a human voice, repetitions finding a rhythm. We hear a musician becoming a writer — not a wild a leap, he observes in conversation.

The differences between being a rock drummer and writing are superficial. The obvious ones: you’re playing with a couple of other people on stage, and you’re doing it at an ungodly volume. I’m clinically half deaf and I have tinnitus and a ringing in my ear all the time. But writing scratches the same itch… Having been a drummer I write by ear. I write by rhythm, you know. I just think of the rhythm of the sentence, and there’s a certain number of beats in a sentence, in a phrase, in longer passages. So there’s a kind of arranging. And then certainly in all these multigenerational things going on in Tinkers, I’m just fascinated by the experience of time, of being in time, and all these characters thinking about time and all that. As a drummer… you can futz around with all sorts of time signatures and all sorts of beats. You can play a time signature within another time signature. You can do all that sort of stuff. It’s all narrative, and narrative is all about time. So that’s what you’re doing with the writing, too.

I saw Elvin Jones of the famous Coltrane quartet several dozen times and had the opportunity to sit right in front of him and watch what he did with time. He could tap into the depths of the universe… Drumming is multi-tasking, it’s orchestration. You think of it as a string quartet — in the way you can play counterpoint with yourself, with your own different limbs, that kind of thing. I think of that as the way of making narrative, too. Any given scene has different strata. You can have things moving very nimbly, very quickly in one level of the writing, with larger, deeper cycles going on beneath. And you can work all that contrast and counterpoint. It’s the way you actually pull depth and dimensionality out of things.

Paul Harding in conversation with Chris Lydon, in Essex, Massachusetts, May 5, 2009.

Paul Harding is also a self-taught modern New England transcendentalist, out of the Thoreau and Emerson school, who read his way into an original inner life. Marilynne Robinson at the Iowa Writers Workshop eased his transition from the drums to the keyboard. He’s read everything — been touched by Henry James and Proust and Carlos Fuentes and Michael Ondatje, among others — and he’s taught writing at Harvard.

Tinkers — as in country peddlars between the 19th and early 20th centuries — is an almost plotless novel, constructed as carefully as a clock, about fathers dying, thinking about their sons, and their fathers. It is a marvel on every page.

Related Content

  • zeke

    I had the good fortune of hearing Paul Harding in Portsmouth, NH at our wonderful, local independent bookstore, Riverrun Books. He was engaging, informative and unassuming. It was clear that this is a book written to express things that are important to its author not to accomodate the marketplace. I hope it will find many readers.

  • hurley

    That was fun. I especially look forward to the matter of the clocks. There’s a wonderful strain in American literature of describing how things are made. Contemporary favorites Philip Roth’s description in American Pastoral of how to make a glove, and Cormac McCarthy’s wonderful set-piece in Outer Dark (I think), where a blacksmith gives a not very bright would-be apprentice a beautiful, painstakingly detailed three or four page lesson in how to make a knife, at the end of which he says,

    “And that’s how you do it.”

    “Do what?”

    Or something like that. Grateful for other examples, and for the show.

    • Jeff C.

      Don’t forget Don DeLillo’s segment in “Underworld” where the Jesuit priest names the various parts of a shoe. Also a very nice passage!

  • jimmcdowell

    Astounding podcast! Absolutely loved every minute! Have listened multiple times and I share Chris’ enthusiasm with Paul while hearing them interact and can’t wait to pick up the book. I hope he comes back soon.

    In my mind, Paul joins Bloom, Jonah Lehrer, Bob Richardson, and the Coltrane gang, as my favorite interviews.

    Jim McDowell

  • Scott Ralph

    Loved the interview, and ordered the book moments after the podcast!

    Missing my beloved Massachusetts and New England, hearing the lovely Maine descriptions made me pine.

  • Saundra

    Loved the interview! I feel inspired to study the craft of writing more! Can’t wait to read the book!

  • jjw

    …and now a Pulitzer winner. C.L. a year ahead of the rest of the world.

  • Bryon

    I picked up a copy of Tinkers at the Bound Brook, NJ library in January, 2009….Since the initial run of the book was 3,500 copies I had to have been one of the first people in the country to read the book. Since then I’ve continued thinking about parts of the book and how impacting and haunting it was. I was thrilled when I read it had won the Pulitzer; I felt like I had been there from the beginning! Thanks, Paul!

  • Margot Soven

    Although very different in structure, Tinkers reminds me a bit of The Optimist’s Daughter/ I like Welty’s book better because the narrative interest is interwoven with memories–a richer text.

    PS I met your office mate, Greg. in of all places, Israel!

  • Ted MacDonald

    Exceptional interview, in my book. Chris displays genuine delight in exploring Paul’s ideas and leaves Paul alone to fully meander through his very descriptive and enlightening responses. I am half way through the book now and am enjoying it a great deal, my wife having given it to me as a Christmas gift as a result of a very complimentary review in DownEast Magazine. Thank you Paul and Chris for a great interview!

    What caught my attention about the book, and Paul, first was the mention in DownEast that Paul had frequented 1st West Branch Pond above Greenville, Maine…a favorite location of mine and the stomping ground of a beloved old Maine guide, now deceased, who personified an appreciation of the north woods of Maine…I get the sense in reading the book that Paul has drawn a good deal from his experience in that country.