Just Say No!

Millions of people marched over the weekend, showing the outlines of a global, feminist, anti-racist, anti-Trump resistance… maybe. The question on our minds this week is whether the protesters can sustain and direct their dissent to create real political and economic change.

Nobody can predict exactly how Trump’s agenda will play out, and the first days haven’t been good — the non-stop volley of tweets, executive orders, appointments, and headlines. Attention has been paid, Mr President. Now what? Without the institutional structures of old — party, unions, media, and churches — what’s the path of most resistance?

Our guest L.A. Kauffman helped organize the New York anti-war protests in 2003 and 2004, and has written a new book for Verso called Direct Action: Protest and the Reinvention of American Radicalism. She traces U.S. movements after the 1960s, from Earth First to ACT UP to the Seattle WTO protests to Occupy and beyond. She is euphoric about the possibilities of “upbeat unruliness” to transform our current, dismal political reality.

Protesters in in D.C., where an estimated 500,000 people marched, and New York, where 400,000 people came out. Hundreds of thousands more marched around the world, including at least 750,000 in Los Angeles. Photos by Zach Goldhammer and Conor Gillies.

Still, we wonder how a huge array of ordinary folks, of every political stripe — from Hillary Clinton fans to the antifa Black Bloc (a.k.a. the folks burning limos and punching Nazis) — with nothing more in common than their dislike of Trump, can mobilize within the current structure of electoral politics (and a Democratic party already failing to “present a united front to defend human rights and civil liberties in the Trump era”). Some wonder if it’s even worthwhile working within institutions that have brought us continued war, poverty, and inequality.

Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor, Princeton professor, socialist organizer, and author of From #BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation, offers a broad-tent vision of grassroots resistance mixed with a healthy dose of cynicism about traditional political leadership. In a widely-shared statement this week, Taylor encouraged Americans to build social movements outside of existing party politics. She disregards the Democrats as revisionists, who throughout the 20th century have worked to absorb, contain, and de-radicalize social movements (black liberation movements in particular). But Prof. Taylor critiques are aimed primarily at the ruling political class; she discourages organizers from harping on whether whether or not the street-level marchers were too white, too liberal, or too #StillWithHer: “The women’s marches were the beginning, not the end. …There are literally millions of people in this country who are now questioning everything. We need to open up our organizations, planning meetings, marches, and much more to them.”

Mark Greif, founding editor of the magazine n+1 and author of a new essay collection, Against Everything, takes the position of a born contrarian when it comes to the new administration: “No President” — not “not my president” — has been his motto since the election and civil disobedience remains his default stance. Greif, like us, is deeply influenced by the New England transcendentalists, and forces us to ask, WWTD (what would Thoreau do)? The answer may lie in Thoreau’s own question: “The laws are there. Do they really represent you? What would it take for them to represent you?” Cultivate inefficiency, and don’t be afraid to be a crank, Greif says. “Be yourself friction, inside the machine.” Hear a longer interview with Greif below:

We’re joined in the studio by minister-activist Mariama White-Hammond and The Tea Party chronicler Vanessa Williamson.

Watch producer Zach Goldhammer’s interviews from the Women’s March below:

illustration by Susan Coyne

Guest List
Mark Greif
Essayist and founding editor of the magazine n+1. Mark Greif show transcript
L. A. Kauffman
Organizer, strategist, journalist, and author of Direct Action: Protest and the Reinvention of American Radicalism.
Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor
Author, organizer, and member of the International Socialist Organization.
Mariama White-Hammond
Minister, activist, and artist.
Vanessa Williamson
Fellow in Governance Studies at Brookings and author of The Tea Party and the Remaking of the Republican Party.

Related Content

  • Great show – lots of varying viewpoints. Mariama White-Hammond was a standout for me – I want to be in her congregation; as Chris said, she is magic.

    About two years ago I started a journey to find the answer to why radical activists think it is okay to kill another human being for an idea. Obviously the idea is to make a better world but they seem to have no compunction about killing a few of us sheeple – which amounts to throwing over one ideology for another. It was filmic journey which meant documentaries and fictional films (Robert Kramer – who was the real deal, btw). Films about Baader-Meinhof, The Red Brigades, SDS, Weather Underground, Black Panthers, various utopian collectives, cults, and oh yes, the Punk genre of music.

    It ended rather ironically with a Canadian group avowed not to kill other humans (though mistakes do happen). The significance of this group was that one of the leaders started out in the 1970s wanting to be an activist as a career choice. Upon leaving prison he was interviewed. It was during this interview that I had what I believe to be an insight into the leaders of these groups. They don’t relate one-on-one with people but see people collectively, as a way-to-power.

    The White-Hammond/Williamson approach is the antithesis to a past radical activism centered on corrupt individuals (Mark Greif: am I like Hillary or am I like Donald) but proposes a space where one-on-one people can be anchored by their feelings for Democracy.

  • Potter

    At this moment I don’t see any possibility of an overlap between Trump supporters and non-supporters. Such is the difference in views ( of what is fact), goals, values, much less how to proceed. Yes of course, we must resist in every way because it is really a war. We should only be smart about it.

    Take a deep breath, “buckle your seat belts; we are in for a wild ride”…the last words of part two of Frontline’s “The Divided States of America”

  • Potter

    Compare and contrast please:
    In Venezuela, we couldn’t stop Chávez. Don’t make the same mistakes we did.

    (PS. The author is now living in Madrid)

  • GWelch

    Bernie’s Socialism is not substantially different than FDR’s New Deal. I think that most Americans would be on board with that.

  • Potter
  • WoozyCanary

    Where will the movement get the money? C’mon Chris. From the people! $27 at a time. (Average contribution to the Sanders campaign)

    And, yes, the enterprise needs a name.

    Great show!

  • mem_somerville

    LA Kauffman, scholar of protest movements (my transcription):

    “…The first lesson is that protest works. Movements that have a protest component
    and particularly that have a very strong and emphatic protest component on the whole are
    more successful at either protecting gains or winning gains than those that stick
    to petitions and lobbying and legislative work, work that’s kind of in the standard
    channels of government.”

    I am seeing a lot of really helpful manplaining around the March for Science lately. Nobody is saying that a march will lead to the Trump administration caving the next day. But building alliances matters very much for working the other routes as well.

  • Will W.

    Cosmopolitan globalists believe in open borders, open trade, and unending globalization. The elites at Davos distain nationalism and other such populist sentiments. Trump bluntly believes in securing the Southern border, compelling U.S. industry back home, and in the robust economic nationalism of “America First” regardless of cost. In doing so he is at odds with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Fortune 500 who lobbied for NAFTA and GATT. Trump is also up against the big guns in Silicone Valley, the Koch Bros. machine, the new Women’s movement, BLM and the rest of the Left. It’s an epic struggle and a hard one to imagine the Trump family winning.

    But Resistance is just a word. Dethroning Trump isn’t enough without an alternate road down business-as-usual in an age of globalization – otherwise we’re the just Useful Idiots of the Koch Brothers, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Fortune 500.